Download An Album, Go To Prison?

Federal prosecutors in Los Angeles are pursuing a 6-month prison term for a Los Angeles man who pleaded guilty in December to one misdemeanor count of uploading pre-release Guns N’ Roses tracks, according to court documents.

Read the full article here.

I’ve been following these articles about digital rights management (or as I prefer to call it, digital restriction management) and “illegal downloading” and all the other garbage that the music industry is regurgitating in an effort to maintain their cartel. The article linked above takes the cake.

While the guy that leaked the Chinese Democracy album does deserve some form of punishment, I think 6 months in prison is an over the top bully tactic for both the government and the recording industry, especially considering the “crime” he committed is considered a misdemeanor. It seems to me that a fine of a couple hundred dollars is a bit more reasonable than prison time. Hell, you’d be better off going to Best Buy and stealing it from there. The punishment for getting caught would be much less severe and you wouldn’t have the stigma of having been in prison on your record.

Times are changing and the music cartel doesn’t want to evolve. What scares them most is that with digital distribution, music consumers can pick and choose the songs they want as opposed to being force fed the filler music you find on most releases. I’ve found that the people I know that purchase music on iTunes, Napster, Rhapsody, etc. actually spend more money because since they’re picking only the songs they want, they’re buying more songs. The phrase “you can’t see the forest for the trees” rings true here.

The bottom line is that the Internet has changed the way the music industry operates, whether they like it or not and it would be in their best interest to find a way to use some form of digital distribution to their advantage.

Share on Facebook

1 Comment


  1. //

    What is so odd here, and good points Al, is that the record industry forced us all to go to the “digital” format in the first place…They created the monster that they no longer can control…My wife and I went to a bar the other day, (I swear to God just…the other day 🙂 REO Speedwagon reference…lol) the internet jukebox cost two bucks per song and I could have bought the songs on line cheaper than that. To the record companies …I say …your dug your grave, now go lay in it…it’s game over…the people now have to the power to speak…and for artists that only write one good song per album…well, if you want us to buy the whole album then you do your part and step up on the writing and quit feeding us junk…see u on limewire 😉
    chuck

Comments are closed.